If you have not but, observe us on X (Twitter), Mastodon, or Bluesky to know after we publish new articles, and be part of our Reddit or Subscribe to us on YouTube to take a look at our content material and work together with our superior neighborhood. Thanks for supporting us!
There have been a variety of developments within the Steam Deck area, however none have been as massive and divisive as what has occurred with the Steam Deck subreddit. r/SteamDeck is among the largest communities for Steam Deck customers and has more and more grown since its launch in 2021, however within the final 12 months or two, it has been marred with controversies surrounding its high mod. There was additionally a variety of controversy surrounding SteamDeckHQ and myself personally, as any hyperlinks or point out of us was instantly eliminated and will lead to a ban.
However, seemingly out of nowhere, the highest mod was eliminated, giving entry to different moderators who’ve tried to show the sub round and again to its former glory. Up to now, the crew has been very communicative and even introduced me on to assist average to each prolong an olive department and assist enhance the sub with suggestions, which I accepted. I additionally even helped draft the brand new guidelines that had been applied, with a variety of my focus being on the brand new self-promotion guidelines (which I’m additionally subjected to).
Now that I’m a mod, I also can see a few of what has occurred because it occurred through modmail. So, I wished to go over precisely what occurred and the way we (SteamDeckHQ) turned concerned in it. One of many moderators, House_of_Suns, posted about their account of what occurred on the subreddit, which matches a little bit extra into the historical past of the sub and the way it acquired to the place it’s now. I’ll briefly contact on a few of these, so I like to recommend trying out the publish in order for you extra info from the beginning of the sub.
I may even not be giving particular names as we do not wish to promote directing any hate or hurt to this particular person.
The Starting of the Points
As House_of_Suns mentions in his publish, the beginning of the problems dates again a bit additional than a variety of us could know. There have been three generations of moderators in complete, with members of the third technology nonetheless part of the crew at this time. Each the primary and second generations had been instrumental in build up the subreddit to what it’s at this time however had been primarily purged utterly with the highest mod invoking their powers as “the founder and top-moderator of r/SteamDeck.” In line with accounts from each first- and second-generation moderators, these got here after the highest moderators didn’t talk with the crew and made choices that had been opposite to the principles of the sub.
I can verify that each generations of mods tried to increase an olive department and work with the highest mod, inviting them to their very own moderator discord to speak extra successfully and giving them the good thing about the doubt, however they weren’t responsive and denied invites. The second technology of moderators acquired annoyed with the highest mod’s lack of responses and breaking their very own guidelines, and collectively put collectively a message for them stating:
A number of members of the moderation crew are very involved about your conduct. Between brashly nuking the entire dbrand posts with out speaking to anybody, and now your “F” publish CLEARLY breaking our guidelines, then BANNING SOMEONE for calling you out, one thing’s acquired to offer. You refuse to hitch the discord all the moderation crew makes use of, which is ok. What is not high-quality is your rash actions with out speaking to anybody…You retain making messes and anticipating all of us to scrub up after you. This isn’t okay. You are also very clearly breaking Reddit’s Moderator code of conduct…
Collective assertion from Third Technology of Moderators
And the highest mod’s response to what was:
Now whether or not you personally and/or the opposite moderators have an opinion on whether or not I’m ‘worthy’ of the highest mod place is essentially irrelevant to our duty to the sub-reddit and it is members. You were not introduced on board to query that and that’s NOT for you or some other mod to determine. Do it on Discord, inside different subs you mod or in your private life. However not right here on the official channels by dangerous religion political assaults aimed toward me only for holding the place. Lets get one factor clear: YOU don’t converse for the mods. In a single collective voice, that is my privilege & duty as high moderator. I converse for the mod positions and all the r/steamdeck sub-reddit on all issues that require one voice. You occupy the function of moderator as a result of I created it in the most effective curiosity of the sub. You might elect your self to talk for fellow moderators on this explicit topic about me. Wonderful. You have appeared to telegraph what you assume which means for you. And admittedly, the opposite moderators have their very own particular person voices are free to talk on this topic. The ground is open to them as properly.
Ex-High Moderator of r/SteamDeckHQ
This was adopted up by one other message from the second-generation moderators who wished to work issues out and discover methods to speak:
…we’re keen and wish to provide the probability to show to us that you’ll work with us. In case you conform to decide to the communication paths outlined above AND conform to appropriate your moderation in-line with our neighborhood guidelines, we’ll rescind the report made towards you, and can be completely happy to attempt to work with you to enhance. Nonetheless, for those who proceed to be disconnected from crew discussions, proceed with disregard for our subreddits guidelines, or proceed to attempt to flaunt your “high mod” spot to attempt to beat down opposition, we’ll discover ourselves again right here, with each channel accessible to us to have you ever eliminated as a moderator, in our hand.
Collective assertion from Third Technology of Moderators
Sadly, this resulted in all the second technology crew being ousted, just like what had occurred with the primary technology. Numerous these modifications went largely unnoticed by the neighborhood, and it wasn’t till suppression occurred that others began to note and be extra vocal.
Suppressions and Bans
After the ousting of the final gen, the third technology of the mod crew was instated and helped handle the server on a restricted foundation. The crew had no entry to something apart from the mod queue and was offering assist. There was no entry to something like mod mail or crowd management. Solely the highest mod had clearance. For some time, they hadn’t seen something out of the peculiar, however in the direction of the tip of final 12 months (November 2023), issues began to rear their head.
There have been a variety of spikes within the mod queue, all extra combative, and the highest moderator’s identify was talked about straight. That is additionally when the phrase “Mod” would lead to an auto-removal, and the potential ban would apply to anybody saying the phrase. Whereas that is frequent throughout Reddit, the Steam Deck is a moddable machine, so lots of people had been upset that they could not discuss modifying their machine.
I additionally seen that any SteamDeckHQ hyperlinks I posted on the subreddit can be taken down, and whereas I did observe the self-promo rule, I hadn’t thought a lot of it but.
This all got here to a head even additional when somebody posted about having their Steam Deck with them whereas awaiting surgical procedure, and whereas the mod crew had spent a variety of time eliminating transphobic and bigoted feedback, the publish was nonetheless accepted for the sub. Nonetheless, the highest moderator eliminated the publish, which made a variety of the neighborhood very upset.
The backlash of all of this resulted in one of many mods leaving whereas making observe of the highest moderator’s incapability to speak:
Sorry I am resigning my place as a mod right here. [Top Moderator], I really feel like it’s essential to do a greater job of speaking with the mods. Oftentimes, it appears to take ceaselessly to obtain a response right here, regardless of you making frequent mod actions. Additionally, I really feel form of powerless once I see person complaints about our moderation- since I really feel like I am unable to have a dialog to vary our guidelines, or reply to modmails. Many customers complain concerning the quantity of megathreads, which is not being addressed. (Personally, I by no means use megathreads, so I can see why many individuals are overwhelmed by the sorts of posts gated behind them.) I am posting my reasonings right here as an alternative of in a DM, as a result of I am not attempting to name you out (or some other mods)- I feel there ought to be a greater dialog between the mods sooner or later. I hope that my leaving spurs some constructive dialogue. Additionally on a private observe, coping with customers is aggravating for me, in order that does consider to my determination of leaving. Thanks for the chance and good luck everybody.
Ex-moderator of r/SteamDeckHQ
It did not get higher from right here.
At the beginning of this 12 months (March 2024), a bunch of posts began calling out the highest moderators for his or her conduct, which might limit folks from speaking about modifying their Steam Decks and repressing any criticism. The remainder of the mod crew had no thought however may solely see that there was some difficulty folks had been having with how the sub was being run.
To determine the problems and get neighborhood enter, House_of_Suns created a stickied publish aimed toward getting the enter to listen to concerning the points. This acquired a incredible quantity of engagement with tons of feedback, with customers venting concerning the guidelines, wanting fewer Steam Deck image posts, and concerning the high mods’ conduct. This led Hosue_of_Suns to attempt addressing the issues introduced up with the highest moderator, wanting to herald extra neighborhood engagement and needing extra entry to instruments like mod mail to essentially assist the mod crew do their jobs. Sadly, as an alternative of responding, the highest moderator unstickied and eliminated the publish, which introduced in one other wave of customers being pissed off at administration.
House_of_Suns did inform the highest moderator this was a really poor determination since they had been actively shedding the belief of the neighborhood, they usually responded by saying that this was some coordinated assault/hate marketing campaign they usually simply wish to preserve the present course whereas banning all customers who criticize:
Famous. Stand quick. My opinion is the sub isn’t imploding. The VAST majority of the sub is doing what they do sans the coordinated assault marketing campaign. I’m very a lot conscious of the sentiment. Much more, I’m very a lot conscious of the abuse aimed toward me. Placating the hostility from this marketing campaign (even in an effort to isolate it inside a thread) is giving them a voice to additional amplifty the rhetoric. The technique within the speedy time (as in proper now this second) is to allow them to burn their gasoline. Quite, yeet their shit and permit the neighborhood to proceed what they’re presently doing: Discussing Steam Deck. I’ll NOT give into stress campaigns. I will not tolerate the abuse or threats aimed toward me personally or at you, any mods or the neighborhood. Neither will the Reddit Admins. There’s nothing extra necessary than to take away these toxifying the sub with this hate marketing campaign proper now. The toxicity, the abuse has crossed the road. It could be futile to host a lucid dialogue about enhancements to the sub whereas a marketing campaign like that is in have an effect on
Ex-High Moderator of r/SteamDeckHQ
This was the rhetoric that the highest moderator would proceed to push shifting ahead whereas additionally justifying the restricted entry that the opposite moderators acquired. They even talked about that Reddit Admins had been by some means concerned, which was information to the remainder of the crew.
Round this time, I began to note SteamDeckHQ being banned and myself being focused. Any hyperlinks to the web site had been taken down, whereas any posts I made had been instantly eliminated, even when that they had no point out of the web site. I actually felt slighted when my publish from PAX East this 12 months, (March 2024), was taken down. It was an image of a Steam Deck taking part in New Blood’s Fallen Aces earlier than it had been publicly launched. There was no point out of the web site on the publish, but it was nonetheless taken down. That is once I began to double down and create our personal subreddit, r/SteamDeckHQ, as I began to really feel that these repressive actions had been occurring too usually and for unjustified causes.
In September, there have been a few developments, however in the end, House_of_Suns expressed some issues for the highest moderator’s private well being, the subreddit, and the r/SteamDeckHQ sub getting endorsed from r/Linux_gaming, which ended up changing r/SteamDeck. In response, the highest moderator determined to audit the sub resulting from “brigading” and revoked all mod privileges. This meant all of the mods had no entry to something and had been primarily mods in identify solely.
For context, brigading is a type of on-line harassment that features a coordinated marketing campaign to slander and besmirch an individual or actions to make them appear much less fashionable than they really are. From what I may inform, folks had been calling out conduct that was backed up by proof, and the auto-mod eliminated related info whereas approving rule-breaking posts. Based mostly on this, I might say there was no precise brigading happening.
Round this time, I seen our hyperlinks had been being banned from being posted altogether. I had reached out privately and acquired muted from messaging. Others locally noticed this and tried making posts asking why, and it could lead to a ban. As soon as I discovered about this, I requested folks to not publish or ask since it could lead to a ban, however the injury was already completed. Speaking about any neighborhood apart from r/SteamDeck, mentioning the phrase “mod,” and mentioning one thing that may very well be construed as criticism in the direction of the moderating crew would lead to a near-immediate ban.
Once more, the mod crew had no thought what was occurring and had no permission to see it. It was solely the highest moderator.
The Massive Removing
After this audit announcement, the crew waited a couple of month to see if something would change, however there was nothing. They could not carry out any of their duties since that they had no permissions, and there was no response when asking for any updates from the highest moderator. This led House_of_Suns and moderator Sweatycat to independently report the scenario to the Reddit Admins, who took motion shortly and opened a modmail to the mod crew to research. Nonetheless, the mod crew could not see it since that they had no permission, and after it occurred, the highest moderator utterly eliminated the mod crew, just like the primary and second generations.
However this time was totally different. The admins restored the mod crew and gave them ALL the permissions potential to make sure they could not be de-modded whereas this investigation was underway.
By the investigation, the highest moderator tried to spin a story that the moderators had been colluding with brigaders they usually had been the one ones attempting to defend the neighborhood, which from all of the actions I’ve seen them take, is totally false. The highest mod even tried to publish about needing a brand new mod crew whereas this was occurring, exhibiting that they thought it could go of their favor they usually may get rid of folks disagreeing with them.
Then, the Admins made their determination. The highest moderator was faraway from the subreddit resulting from violating the Moderator Code of Conduct: Rule 1.
This leads us to the place we at the moment are. The brand new mod crew has been spending tons of time cleansing up the mess that was left. They’ve unbanned tons of individuals, clearing out years of mod mail and attempting to fix what was damaged. I can attest to this as properly. House_of_Suns reached out personally to tell us of the change and apologized for the previous conduct. This ended up with us discussing how we may collaborate and work collectively, which resulted in me becoming a member of the mod crew to assist construct it again up.
I’m proud to be on this mod crew, and it has left me with a variety of optimism. Every member appears to be on the identical web page, making the sub higher and returning it to its former glory. The implementation of the brand new guidelines is step one. All of us have been working laborious on it, however I wish to give a particular thanks to moderator NKkrisz, who has been working time beyond regulation to draft and implement these new guidelines. All of the mods are incredible now, they usually have proven this. They really wish to repair the subreddit.
SteamDeckHQ Was A Tipping Level
As a mod, I’ve been in a position to see a few of the historical past behind what had transpired, and a variety of this appeared to correlate with our discovery of SteamDeckHQ being banned. There have been tons of bans throughout September after we found that our hyperlinks had been banned from being posted, with even some folks getting a ban cause stating that they had been “brigaiding for SDHQ” or “brigaiding (in assist) of SDHQ.” Each of those causes are, nonetheless, ridiculous.
We now have by no means as soon as requested anybody else to publish about this occurring, however the quantity of individuals doing it touched our hearts. Once more, I wish to thank everybody who made the choice to take the chance of ban and assist us in that point, it really means a lot to us.
From what I may inform, it looks as if we had been an enormous cause that the highest moderator used to defend their actions. They point out us a number of occasions for “brigading” and point out me straight as collaborating as properly. They linked to a remark I made about creating the SteamDeckHQ subreddit and welcoming folks with out shutting them out, however I do not see how that may justify as brigading since I don’t point out r/SteamDeck or one other moderator. They even talked about they might have congratulated us for our progress if it did not correlate to this “pro-SDHQ marketing campaign,” nonetheless, their actions present in any other case since they might shut down any point out of alternate subs and disabled cross-posting to r/SteamDeck.
They even went on to record a few of our exercise, together with the publish I made the place r/Linux_Gaming changed the sub with our personal. They talked about I used to be advocating for this substitute, however I by no means as soon as requested to interchange r/SteamDeck and solely requested to be added to the sidebar. Different customers made the suggestion, and we had no contact with them in any respect.
They observe that their investigation decided the purpose of origin of those assaults to be r/SteamDeckHQ, which is mindless, contemplating none of us ever advocated for taking motion towards r/SteamDeck. We invited individuals who had been already displeased with the highest moderator’s actions and reassured them it would not be the case right here. We by no means attacked them straight, nor did we point out their identify, however the impression we had been having clearly induced them misery.
It’s a bit fascinating to see simply how a lot of an impression our choices had, and whereas they weren’t precisely why the dialog with the Reddit Admins began, we had been the primary level the highest mod was making to attempt defending their actions, which clearly was not sufficient.
Both approach, I’m more than happy with the course the mods are taking the sub now, and really honored to be part of the crew. As for the highest moderator, I actually hope they’re doing okay and are reflecting on this era. There isn’t any ill-will anymore, and I am unable to wait to see how r/SteamDeck grows from this.
In case you loved this text, try the remainder of the content material on SteamDeckHQ! We now have all kinds of sport evaluations and information that may assist your gaming expertise. Whether or not you are searching for information, suggestions and tutorials, sport settings and evaluations, or simply wish to keep up-to-date on the newest traits, we have you lined!
